What actually happened that night in the woods?
4.996
87 min
In December 1995, a four-man team from the public-access program, "Fact or Fiction", braved the New Jersey's desolate Pine Barrens determined to deliver a live broadcast of the legendary Jersey Devil. Only one came out alive. It took the jury ninety minutes to sentence the lone survivor to life in prison. One year later, a filmmaker decides to mount his own investigation...
| Name | Character | Team | |
|---|---|---|---|
| David Beard | David Leigh, The Filmmaker | Unowned | |
| Jim Seward | Jim Suerd, The Accused | Unowned | |
| Stefan Avalos | Steven Avkast, 'Fact or Fiction' Host | Unowned | |
| Lance Weiler | Locus Wheeler, 'Fact or Fiction' Host | Unowned | |
| Rein Clabbers | Rein Clackin, Paranormal Sound Man | Unowned | |
| Michele Pulaski | Michelle Monarch, Data Retrieval Expert | Unowned | |
| Tom Brunt | Tom Branski, Technical Director of 'Fact or Fiction' | Unowned | |
| Mark Rublee | Clair Deforest, Editor for the Prosecution | Unowned | |
| A.D. Roso | Anthony Rosi, Lead Investigator of Murders | Unowned | |
| Dale Worstall | Dr. Dale Orstall, Jim's Child Psychologist | Unowned | |
| Vann K. Weller | Dr. Vann Waller - Forensic Pathologist | Unowned | |
| Sam Wells | Sam Woods - Television Soap Director | Unowned | |
| Jay MacDonald | Jay McDowell, Web Designer | Unowned | |
| Faith Weiler | Joyce Dryer, Jim's Landlady | Unowned | |
| Marianne Connor | Mary Brenner, TV Reporter | Unowned | |
| Robert Weiler | Barry Williams - Editor of The Baroake County Record | Unowned | |
| Jennifer Nasal | 911 operator (voice) | Unowned | |
| Brett Nielsen | Man Struck by Lightning Three Times | Unowned | |
![]() |
Holly Madison | Miss Lady Bright Eyes | Unowned |
| Jeremy Coleman | Ray - 'Fact or Fiction' Cameraman | Unowned | |
| Todd Weiler | Ricky - "Fact or Fiction" Cameraman | Unowned | |
| Chadd Ritenbaugh | Man with Guitar | Unowned |