| Name | Character | Team | |
|---|---|---|---|
| DJ Perry | Jesus | Unowned | |
![]() |
Rance Howard | Devil as an Old Man | Unowned |
![]() |
Dan Haggerty | Yahweh | Unowned |
![]() |
Joe Cipriano | Young Jesus | Unowned |
| Shane Hagedorn | Gabriel | Unowned | |
| Melissa Anschutz | Mary | Unowned | |
| Drew Wise | Unowned | ||
| Terry Jernigan | Unowned | ||
![]() |
Taylor Nichols | Unowned | |
| Taymour Ghazi | Unowned | ||
![]() |
Eddie Kaulukukui | Unowned | |
| Dean Teaster | Unowned | ||
![]() |
Logan Kishi | Unowned | |
| Rebecca Lawlor | Unowned | ||
| Stetson Bloomfield | Unowned | ||
| Anthony Hornus | Unowned | ||
| Robert Bradley | Unowned |