6.623
100 min
Filmmaker Liz Garbus investigates the mysterious tragedy of Diane Schuler in an effort to understand what went wrong.
| Name | Character | Team | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jesse Temple | Self (voice) (archive sound) | Unowned | |
| Brad Katinas | Self (voice) (archive sound) | Unowned | |
| Diane Schuler | Self (voice) (archive sound) | Unowned | |
| Jay Schuler | Self - Diane's Sister-in-Law | Unowned | |
| Michael Realmuto | Self (archive footage) | Unowned | |
| Daniel Schuler | Self - Diane's Husband | Unowned | |
| Jimmy Schuler | Self - Daniel's Brother & Jay's Husband | Unowned | |
| Warren Hance | Self - Diane's Brother (voice) (archive sound) | Unowned | |
| Dominic Barbara | Self - Schuler Attorney | Unowned | |
| Evan Schuler | Self - Jay's Son | Unowned | |
| Ann Scott | Self - Owner, Hunter Lake Campground | Unowned | |
| James Boyle | Self - Investigator, New York State Police | Unowned | |
| Joseph Becerra | Self - Investigator, New York State Police | Unowned | |
| Michael E. Archer | Self - Accident Reconstructionist | Unowned | |
| Bryan Schuler | Self - Sole Survivor of Accident | Unowned | |
| Roseann Guzzo | Self - Guy Bastardi's Sister | Unowned | |
| Margaret Nicotina | Self - Guy Bastardi's Sister | Unowned | |
| Joseph Longo | Self - Daniel Longo's Brother | Unowned | |
| Gerald Salerno | Self - Witness | Unowned | |
| Francis Bagley | Self - Witness | Unowned | |
| Jean Bagley | Self - Witness | Unowned | |
| Kristine Puvogel | Self - Diane's Childhood Friend | Unowned | |
| Michelle Federlein | Self - Diane's Childhood Friend | Unowned | |
| Nicole Messina | Self - Diane's Childhood Friend | Unowned | |
| Harold Bursztajn | Self - Forensic Psychiatrist, Harvard Medical School | Unowned | |
| Irene Schuler | Self - Daniel's Mother | Unowned | |
| Joseph Schuler | Self - Daniel's Father | Unowned | |
| Sue Troccoli | Self – Diane's Coworker | Unowned | |
| Noreen Smyth | Self - Diane's Friend | Unowned | |
![]() |
Oprah Winfrey | Self (archive footage) | Calvin and Nobbs |
| Tom Ruskin | Self - Private Investigator (voice) | Unowned | |
| Steve Fishman | Self - Journalist, New York Magazine | Unowned | |
| Christine Lipani | Self - Diane's Best Friend | Unowned | |
| Kenneth J. Cano | Self - Zone Sergeant, New York State Police | Unowned | |
| Betsy Spratt | Self - Director of Toxicology, Westchester County | Unowned | |
| Carol Weiss | Self - Addiction Psychiatrist, Weill Cornell Medical College | Unowned | |
| Peter Royal | Self - Witness | Unowned | |
| Elaine Royal | Self - Witness | Unowned | |
| Peter Grotto | Self - Witness | Unowned | |
| Emily Friedberg | Self - Witness | Unowned | |
| Richard Morel | Self - Witness | Unowned | |
| Lorna Ramos-Morel | Self - Witness | Unowned | |
| Werner Spitz | Self - Medical Examiner | Unowned | |
| Edward Blaikie | Self - Witness | Unowned | |
| Kevin Martz | Self - Witness | Unowned | |
| Joseph LaGrippo | Self - Former Chief, Hawthorne Fire Department | Unowned | |
![]() |
Liz Garbus | Self - Interviewer (voice) | Unowned |