| Name | Character | Team | |
|---|---|---|---|
![]() |
Sydney Sweeney | Penny Jo Poplin | Calvin and Nobbs |
![]() |
Paul Walter Hauser | Lefty Ledbetter | Calvin and Nobbs |
![]() |
Halsey | Mandy Starr | Unowned |
![]() |
Simon Rex | Roy Lee Dean | The Free Refills |
![]() |
Eric Dane | Dillon Macintosh | Unowned |
![]() |
Zahn McClarnon | Ghost Eye | Unowned |
![]() |
Derek Hinkey | Hank Spears | Unowned |
![]() |
Toby Huss | Pendleton Duvall | Unowned |
![]() |
Harriet Sansom Harris | Tish | Unowned |
![]() |
Joe Adler | Fun Dave | Unowned |
| Gavin Maddox Bergman | Cal Starr | Unowned | |
![]() |
Donald Cerrone | Sheriff Cole Pickering | Unowned |
![]() |
Jasper Keen | Reggie Dale | Unowned |
![]() |
Austin Boyce | Brittany Gable | Unowned |
![]() |
Megan Hensley | Sarah | Unowned |
![]() |
Christopher Kriesa | Hiram Bruce Starr | Unowned |
![]() |
Brannon Cross | Jeremiah | Unowned |
| Brady Box | Spence | Unowned | |
| Augusta Allen-Jones | Grace | Unowned | |
![]() |
Daved Wilkins | Albert | Unowned |
![]() |
Ines France Ware | Chandra | Unowned |
| Nancy L. Gray | Donna | Unowned | |
| Rhiannon Frazier | Abigail Starr | Unowned | |
| Kenzie Shea Ross | Abigail Starr | Unowned | |
![]() |
Emily Perry | Calliope Starr | Unowned |
![]() |
Kevin Wiggins | Elroy | Unowned |
![]() |
Alex Knight | Isaac | Unowned |
![]() |
Marisilda Garcia | Melinda | Unowned |
| Bruce Klefstad | Old Wim | Unowned | |
![]() |
Rocko Reyes | Laborer (uncredited) | Unowned |
![]() |
Tony Tost | Cowboy Outside Bar / Country Radio DJ (uncredited) | Unowned |