| Name | Character | Team | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Maggie Marshall-Rousis | Agatha | Unowned | |
| Timothy Carmello | Allistair | Unowned | |
| Christina Lanni | Aubrianna | Unowned | |
| Alli Kelly | Callista | Unowned | |
| Dan Magro | Cole Kirkland | Unowned | |
| Amanda Louden | Concerned Citizen | Unowned | |
![]() |
Sarah Dewey | Council Member Golddust | Unowned |
| Marni Bressler | Council Member Unicorn | Unowned | |
| Jamie Branagh | Jeffery | Unowned | |
| Liz O'Leary | Judge Werewolf | Unowned | |
| Angie Schlauch | Lucie | Unowned | |
| Rachel Gitlevich | Magical Council Cat | Unowned | |
| Ronald A. Magro | Magical Council Owl | Unowned | |
| Susan Hoare | Mrs. James | Unowned | |
| Malia A. Dawkins | Yasmina | Unowned |